Tagged: Stainless. Both are excellent finishes that are very hard, smooth and high performing. DLC outperforms nitride by about the same amount that nitride outperforms phosphate. This is on the basis of hardness and corrosion resistance. …. On the basis of bang for the buck, nitride wins.Learn the differences and advantages of phosphate and nitride coatings for AR barrels. Nitride offers better protection, accuracy and cost, while phosphate is better for full auto …Nitride vs Phosphate. PSA ProductsAR-15. nvpurk October 16, 2021, 7:13pm 6. Personally I like nitride, but there are some possible problems with it. I've read that the nitriding process heats the metal to over 1000 deg F. Although it hardens the metal surface very well with the chemical process, the heat could cause problems with metal's ...4 Sept 2023 ... People often to say Which is better nitride or chrome lined barrel? The nitrided barrels lasted an average of 28,000 shots before rejection.It is much harder to turn out an accurate chrome lined barrel than a Melonite barrel. Well, so they say. A barrel that is going to be chrome lined is specially cut to make room for the considerable thickness of the chrome plating. Now, unlike Electroless Nickel, chrome plating does not go on perfectly even.Nitride vs. Phosphate Finishes: Differences & Considerations By Peter Cahill • 05 Feb, 2024 Explore the practical distinctions between nitride and phosphate finishes in the world of firearms and gain valuable insights to make an informed decision.1. Nitride is much harder than hard chrome. That means comparable barrel life under more typical civilian use. 2. Nitride does not merely treat the bore, it is a surface hardening at the molecular level of the entire barrel, protecting not only the bore, but also the exterior of the barrel from abrasion or scratches.MIL-SPEC is manganese phosphate, which requires oil to provide excellent corrosion resistance on the outside of the barrel. Mag phos typically has a matte grey finish. Nitride. Instead of adding material to the bore (like Chrome lining), Nitride treats the existing steel by imbuing nitrogen into the steel itself.The next upper would be my favorite overall setup. 16" mid-length with a 13.5" M-LOK free-floating barrel and Nitride barrel. PSA 16" Nitride Free Floating Now you get the benefit of not having an FSB which helps the weight balance, and also having a free-floating handguard that increases accuracy by taking away contact points on the barrel.Nitride creates a very hard surface. It will be more scratch resistant , slicker and foul less. If you shoot a lot the barrel will last longer but in the heat/velocity range of a muzzle loader you would need to shoot an astronomical amount to burn out a barrel. It also creates a pleasant dark gray finish. Jun 20, 2019.Nitride vs Phosphate. PSA ProductsAR-15. bfoosh006 July 18, 2021, 4:16pm 3. Nitride. For general purpose. For chrome lined barrels, phosphate…. IE, FN CHF CL. ( I think that is the only way they come… in case anyone did not know. 1 Like.With today's typical 1:9 twist rate, a conventional steel barrel should last about 3,000 rounds, a chrome moly steel alloy should last about 5,000 rounds. A stainless steel barrel should last at least 7,500 rounds and a high quality chrome lined barrel should last at least 10,000 rounds.Although phosphate holds lubricant better than nitride, I think I like the nitride more. The thing with an ar 15 BCG is that the contact surfaces are actually pretty small, the whole carrier isnt being drug through the upper, and phosphate isnt a very hard wearing finish.16" 5.56 Government Profile Midlength AR 15 Barrel, Modern Series. Our 5.56 chambered 16 inch Government Profile Mid-Length Modern Series Barrel is machined from CrMoV steel with a QPQ Corrosion Resistant Finish and QPQ coated M4 feed ramp extension.The barrel that my buddy had issues with would rupture a case when he fired it. It looked like the case was cut perfectly with a razor blade about a quarter inch up from the base. ... Brownells nitride 308 bcg, Ballistic Advantage 18 inch fluted premium barrel, Vortex Diamondback HP 4-16x42 (temporarily), Magpul UBR gen 2 (also cerakoted FDE by ...The only thing i see is the Nitride vs Phosphate barrel finish. I don't think it would really matter either way. Reply reply 38_Special_Ed • I didn't know those were barrel finishes. Thanks to you, I was able to look up the differences. And you're right. It doesn't really ...Jan 19, 2017 · Nitride, Melonite and phosphate are all surface treatments - not coatings. If it says the barrel is nitride finished, it means the barrel is finished with a nitride treatment - and all that entails. If it is finished in phosphate, it is finished with a phosphate treatment of the barrel.1. Anodizing. An anodized gun coating is easily one of the best options available. This particular finish produces a robust hardness that's pretty much second only diamonds! Anodizing requires initiating an electrochemical process that helps to protect steel against corrosion.Chrome lined barrels handle heat better than CMV, SS or Nitride/Melonite/QPQ CMV/SS barrels. The chrome is applied over a rifled bore so there can a variation of thickness of the chrome. A little harder to hold tolerance when applying chrome to a rifled bore which can affect the accuracy of the barrel. Chrome Lined barrels are preferred in full ...However, one advantage of QPQ, the process treats both the inside and the outside of the barrel. QPQ Advantages: Retains the base accuracy of the bore prior to any treatment. Incredible hardness; Better corrosion resistance; Less expensive than Chrome Lining and Phosphate. Can I shoot a .223 round out of a 5.56 NATO barrel?Nitride, Melonite and phosphate are all surface treatments - not coatings. If it says the barrel is nitride finished, it means the barrel is finished with a nitride treatment - and all that entails. If it is finished in phosphate, it is finished with a phosphate treatment of the barrel.Watch this video to find out about the many different ceiling options available including vaulted, cathedral, recessed, dropped, tray, barrel, and coffered. Expert Advice On Improv...Learn how nitride and phosphate finishes differ in terms of hardness, corrosion resistance, wear resistance, and cost for firearm components. Compare the benefits and drawbacks of each finish and choose the best option for your needs.is probably giving him the impression that the chrome lined barrels aren't any better than the Nitride barrels. The fact that both include a similar gas tube that breaks around the same temperature, as designed, doesn't tell us anything about the quality of the barrels themselves. So under real world conditions nitride may still hold up as well.The resulting porosity in nitrided materials allows the coating to last dramatically longer than phosphate- or black-oxide-coated steels. Some manufacturers utilize blanket aerospace specifications such as AMS 2757 or AMS 2959/12 because they encompass the desired porosity and case hardness depth for nitrided firearms components.Chrome Line Barrels. Gun Tech Caleb takes a look at the difference between Nitride and Chrome Lined Barrels. For over 85 years, shooters, professional gunsmiths, hobbyists, military/law enforcement armorers, hunters, and gun tinkerers have turned to for high-quality , , and . You’ll find over 50,000 products from and hard-to-find unique gun ...3 models Watchtower Firearms 16in Wylde Nitride Fluted Barrel (4) $229.99 (Save 13%) $199.99 3 models Criterion Barrels AR-15 Mid-Length Gas Core Threaded Barrel (1) $329.99 (Save $16.50) $313.49 Free 2 Day Shipping. 2 models Criterion Barrels AR-15 Hybrid Mid ...Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.Its very easy usually to tell phosphate from nitride. Phosphate is a dull grey color and usually a little rougher. Nitride is usually black or blue and very smooth. One of nitrides positive attributes is that it is very slick and corrosion resistant. Old phosphate barrels can be a little slicker and shiny just from wear or exposure to lubricantsAR barrel steel is the base metal that the finish and coating goes over. As the foundation, it is important up to a point. There are four main steels used to create AR-15 barrels, the last of which could broadly be called “stainless steel.”. As it happens, several types of stainless steel are commonly used in barrel-making, which we’ll ...Black nitride barrels can be identified by their beautiful glossy black appearance and are often a favorite of AR-15 hobbyists. Parkerizing Also known as phosphating, parkerizing involves submerging the part into a bath of phosphoric acid with the addition of copper and chlorates which is then heated to around 99 degrees Celsius …Nitride is also more brittle than a phosphate coating, making it more difficult to stake properly. Bexar works around this by using round-tipped screws on their staking jig, greatly reducing the chance of it cracking during staking. That said, the primary wear area on a BCG is where the bolt rides. That area is chrome lined on a phosphate BCG ...Nov 11, 2021 · Learn the differences and advantages of phosphate and nitride coatings for AR barrels. Nitride offers better protection, accuracy and cost, while phosphate is better for full auto fire and durability.Scenario: You're picking out a barrel for your new AR-15 rifle build. You discover you have a choice between a chrome-lined or a nitrided barrel. So which is...Cerakote is a tough, thin, and protective ceramic coating that offers superb corrosion resistance, is exceptionally resistant to scratches and tolerates extreme heat — up to 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit. The coating is easily applied to metal, composite and plastic surfaces. This attribute paired with the customizable coloring capabilities makes ...It is 0.05 mm (0.0020 in) thick and produces a 64 Rockwell C hardness rating via a 500 °C (932 °F) nitride bath. The final matte, non-glare finish meets or exceeds stainless steel specifications, is 85% more corrosion resistant than a hard chrome finish, and is 99.9% salt-water corrosion resistant.About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright ...3270 posts · Joined 2011. #4 · Mar 20, 2013. I own CHF and standard Palmetto State Armory barrels (Complete Uppers) and the only difference between the two is when the barrels are extremely hot. The CHF barrel seems to hold a little tighter group (Could be my imagination) over the standard barrel. But as far as longevity of either …and the other part of the conversation "...nitride is cheaper, better tolerances, easier to clean...". one topic that always gets touched on is nitride is easier to clean and CP (chrome phosphate) holds oil better, but the discussion usually stops there even though the threads go on for multiple pages, but that is the major take away. the only ...May 16, 2017 · Phosphate is a dull grey color and usually a little rougher. Nitride is usually black or blue and very smooth. One of nitrides positive attributes is that it is very slick and corrosion resistant. Old phosphate barrels can be a little slicker and shiny just from wear or exposure to lubricants.Any accuracy claims are at best minimal and can be rebuffed by my own personal experience with FN CHF CL barrels. Anybody stating they are definitively harder is reading a nitride vendor spec or a barrel seller spec. Real life is they are not definitively harder, more over they are slightly less than hard chrome.Dec 22, 2020 · Phosphate requires oil or will rust. Nitride is better for accuracy and corrosion resistance than chrome. Chrome will last longer during high use and wear resistance is better than nitride. While phosphate is proven, it's old and pretty much anything besides a bare barrel, bluing, or black oxide will be superior.A fail to feed occurs. Polishing a feed ramp isn't 100% necessary. Many guns function fine without such doting care. Too, other guns function fine when torture tested or run without cleaning to see how many thousands of rounds can be fired to point of failure. None of those guns belong to me.Nitride "locks in" the bore, chrome will add material to it. Benefits of a Nitrided Barrel, Along with that is that the entire barrel, both inside and outside, undergo the same process. In effect, the entire barrel exterior becomes resistant. Chrome, on the other hand, only protects the bore of the barrel. SaveShare.1. Anodizing. An anodized gun coating is easily one of the best options available. This particular finish produces a robust hardness that’s pretty much second only diamonds! Anodizing requires initiating an electrochemical process that helps to protect steel against corrosion.Learn how nitride and phosphate finishes differ in terms of hardness, corrosion resistance, wear resistance, and cost for firearm components. Compare the benefits and drawbacks of each finish and choose the best option for your needs.Advantages and benefits of Ni B, nickel boron, and nitro met, salt bath nitride on AR bolt carrier group, barrel, and gas tube assemblies. This is an inexpensive modern technology process to protect the surface of alloy steel against wear as well as corrosion. The traditional manganese phosphate process on mil spec bolt carrier groups […]Learn the differences and advantages of phosphate and nitride coatings for AR barrels. Nitride offers better protection, accuracy and cost, while phosphate is better for full auto fire and durability.That being said if the chrome line produces groups (just a guess) .75-1.00 MOA and the Nitride can produce something like .65-.85 my vote would be chrome. Not knowing the full difference between the two I would be hard pressed to not go with the standard chrome even if accuracy suffers a tad. You are the expert H, get what you think …Variety of Gun Coating Options. As an industry leader, we are specialized in a variety of firearm finishing treatments, including black oxide, zinc and manganese phosphate, hard anodize, electroless nickel and Teflon. Below, we review these three types of gun finishes, their characteristics, and the benefits associated with each to help guide ...its a hard coating, and is superior to black nitride in surface wear resistance. black nitride hardens the metal to a substantial depth and makes for pretty good wear resistance, and really good long term wear., I prefer black nitride, with the understanding that my gun will have some visible long term wear marks, like a well used glock slide.Faxon Q&A: Barrel Manufacturing, Nitride vs Chrome lining and more! It will definitely increase wear resistance by at least 25 percent. Helps a little with chamber and port erosion but not quite as good as chrome. You do loose some corrosion resistance with stainless when you nitride, but still pretty damn good. Craig.Regular and phosphate are the same, phosphate is the mil spec coating. Similarly, nitride and melonite are the same thing. Phosphate is just fine, requires plenty of lube, but will last a long time. Nitride is a chemical treatment of steel that hardens the steel quite a bit (just the outer layer) and leaves a very smooth finish that has some ...Phosphate is the classic, Nitride is the Freedom, CHF is the premium (historically with an FN Made barrel). There have been other lines through the years, such as PTac, and those have offered other finishes. Stainless is another finish that i think is Freedom line, usually seen on their 308 barrels.Unfortunately, in a recent bulk update most of our descriptions were wiped out. If this video is impacted by this occurrence and a link or code is missing pl...Applying a phosphate coating, better known as parkerizing a firearm, is a type of conversion coating that uses submersion, just like anodizing. In this case, the product is placed in a solution of phosphoric acid. One major benefit of parkerized coatings is that they are self-lubricating. Phosphate provides a porous finish that allows oil to ...Carbine gas ensures any loads will cycle quickly and smoothly, and a mil-spec parts kit with Carbine buffer and M4-type buttstock finishes off the kit. Stainless steel vs parkerized barrel. The US military does buy stainless barrels; but, that's what may be available. Nitride barrels have a smoother bore, which results in more consistent shots.Hard coat anodize in the upper is around low to mid 60's C scale. Some of the PVD and Cvd coatings can be high 60's to low 80's. Parkerizing etches the surface and holds lube. A good parkerized carrier will out live the upper and the user. Craig. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Chrome phosphate vs nitride - BCGs. ARCHIVED.308 Barrel Kit (18″ or 20″) $ 475.00. Review financing options. Price $ 475.00. Add to cart. Shipping & Returns. Return Authorization is required for all returned merchandise. Please email [email protected] or call 407.928.2666 to acquire a Return Merchandise Authorization Number (RMA.) Review our complete Return Policy.Black Nitride vs Phosphate. These are two of the least expensive finishes available. Nitride has the edge when it comes to smoothness and hardness. It also requires less lubricant to work well and is easier to clean. Nitride has many advantages but it is not mil-spec for BCGs and that is an important consideration for some.It has their QPQ finish which is essentially a nitride treatment. QPQ is quench, polish, quench. It is extremely slick and cleans up with the wipe of a rag. DLC on the other hand is a coating as is hard chrome. Nitride is a surface treatment. Any of them are superior to phosphate. Posted: 9/15/2019 11:22:57 AM EDT.Feb 5, 2024 · Learn how nitride and phosphate finishes differ in terms of hardness, corrosion resistance, wear resistance, and cost for firearm components. Compare the benefits and drawbacks of each finish and choose the best option for your needs.Now let's move on to Nitride barrels. Nitride Barrels. These barrels are coated using a slightly different process that actually forms a smooth, dark black hardening of the metal. This finish is applied to both the exterior and interior of the barrel providing rust protection and less maintenance than phosphate. Over the years, Nitride has ...Nitride is a harder and slicker finish than phosphate. Nitride will wear better, last longer, and have less friction than phosphate. There's a reason metal cutting tools (end mills, boring bar inserts, etc) have nitride coatings instead of phosphate. View Quote. There is very minimal wear surface on a bolt carier.Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.Nitride is better than a plain phosphate barrel. A high quality chrome lined barrel is great too but I still prefer nitride. Generally better bang for the buck. I doubt I will shoot out any of my barrels though, even the non chrome lined phosphate so it's not a big deal. Pwhfirefighter, Matteo1371 and crkckr. Like.Cryogenic barrel treatment utilizes liquid nitrogen to bring the temperature of the gun barrel down to -300°F. The gun barrel is kept at this level for 24 hours to relieve residual stresses created during manufacturing. Cryogenic barrel treatment is a one-time, permanent process. The improvement lasts the entire life of the gun or rifle.Both finishes are durable. Nitride is not only coated on the exterior, but in the barrel's bore too. It permeates the metal to give better rust protection. Phosphate is only done on a barrel's exterior surface and not the bore. This is because mil-spec type barrels are chrome-lined first and chrome won't stick to phosphate or any other coating ...4140 Carbon Steel - One of the more common barrel materials which is made up of about 0.4% carbon content. That’s the ‘40’ in 4140 carbon steel. The ‘41’ refers to it being a type of chromium-molybdenum steel. 4150 Carbon Steel - Another one of the more common barrel materials which is made up of 0.5% carbon content.Another rifle I built is approaching 7k rounds, has a newer 4150v nitride barrel from AoA, and it's fresh as could be. Cheap ammo, namely Com bloc steel cased, mild steel copper washed bullets plays hell on barrels. 5,000 hard use rounds is an average barrel's lifespan using steel bullets that have been copper coated.Dec 11, 2017 · The salt bath nitriding process features a few benefits over pre-existing chrome lining technology. The nitriding process serves to enhance corrosion resistance on both the interior and exterior of the barrel. Chrome lined barrels are typically phosphate parkerized to protect the exterior steel from rusting, but this exterior finish does not ...Oct 27, 2016 · Phosphate finishes are just a coating, the are rough on the surface and hold oil well. Better than paint, better than blued steel. Nitride finishes are actual surface treatments to the metal. The high temperature process diffuses nitrogen into the metal actually changing its structure. The surface left is very hard and very corrosion resistant ...Stainless steel gives better accuracy but at the cost of lower overall barrel life. That being said the average shooter doesn’t shoot enough or accurately enough to benefit from stainless steel. Nitride from a production standpoint is also easier to make and generally translates to cheaper barrels/uppers but exceptions do exist. 2 Likes.We're going to find out at what point this rifle will fail and take a look at what the barrel will look like when we get done with it. Sign up for my email l...Nitride is also much better than phosphate for the BCG. Phosphate is just too rough. Nitride has a very smooth almost polished finish that is much easier to clean and slides in the upper much easier. Posted: 1/3/2021 2:15:10 PM EDT. [#12] Quote History. Quoted:Nitride QPQ BCG : r/ar15. NIB Vs. Nitride QPQ BCG. Debating on what BCG to buy for my 300 Blk build. have a NIB in my 5.56 and have heard good things about Nitride QPQ. can someone please elaborate on quality and weigh in on what one I should get. Nitride is my preference. It's almost as slick as NiB, doesn't look so blingy, and the key thing ...Feb 6, 2017 · Nitride is significantly less expensive and less time-consuming for making barrels. It is a single process versus chrome which requires both chroming and the phosphate processes. Is Nitride the same as Melonite, Isonite, Fenocite, QPQ? Faxon typically uses the terms “nitride” and “QPQ” to refer to how our barrels are processed ...32,950. Feedback Score. 14 (100%) My one Chrome carrier sucks at holding lube compared to phosphate. The finish is just too slick/smooth. I have another Fail Zero finish carrier that's even worse. I still run the carriers on range toys, but I definitely prefer phosphate for any serious rifle.Nitride is significantly less expensive and less time-consuming for making barrels. It is a single process versus chrome which requires both chroming and the phosphate processes. Is Nitride the same as Melonite, Isonite, Fenocite, QPQ? Faxon typically uses the terms "nitride" and "QPQ" to refer to how our barrels are processed ...The Traditions™ Performance Firearms barrel protected by Cerakote took 150x longer to show visible signs of corrosion than the barrel treated with Black Nitride Rust Proofing by CVA®. This test video shows that when corrosion protection matters, Cerakote outlasts and outperforms, making it the obvious choice.